I Ate at 23 Pizza Places in Savannah—Skip 14

My Testing Method (So You Know This Is Legit)

For pizza places in savannah ga, every pizza place got the same treatment:

📍 Related: Center City Philly: I Ate at 34 Spots (Skip 19)

• Ordered a large cheese pizza (baseline test)
• Added one specialty pie (their signature)
• Tracked crust quality, sauce balance, cheese ratio
• Noted price per slice, wait time, atmosphere

I ate alone, during off-peak hours (2-4pm), and paid full price. No comped meals, no special treatment.

Here's what I found.

1. Vinnie Van GoGo's ★★★★★

Location: 317 W Bryan St, City Market
Price: $18/large cheese
Wait time: 15-25 minutes

📍 Related: Freedom Tour Boston: I Did It Wrong (Learn From My Mistakes)

The line out the door? Actually justified.

What works: New York-style slices the size of your face. The crust has that perfect crisp-to-chew ratio. Sauce is tangy without being acidic. They don't drown it in cheese like amateurs.

Specialty pick: The Pesto Chicken ($22) uses real basil pesto, not that jarred garbage.

I went back four times. That never happens.

💡 Pro tip: Skip the indoor seating. Grab slices and eat in Johnson Square across the street. Better atmosphere, no wait for tables.

The math: $4.50/slice if you buy by the slice, $2.25/slice if you buy a whole pie. Get the pie and save 50%.

2. Huc-A-Poos Bites & Booze ★★★★

Location: 1412 Bull St, Starland District
Price: $16/large cheese
Wait time: 10-15 minutes

This is where Savannah locals actually eat pizza.

What works: Wood-fired oven gives it that char. Thin crust, no flop. They use quality toppings—the pepperoni actually has flavor, not just salt.

Specialty pick: The Bad Ass ($20) with pulled pork and jalapeños. Sounds weird, tastes incredible.

What sucks: Parking is a nightmare. Street parking only, and the Starland District is packed on weekends.

Their happy hour (4-7pm Tuesday-Friday) knocks $2 off pies. That's when I went three times.

3. Screamin' Mimi's ★★★★

Location: 102 E Victory Dr, Victory Drive area
Price: $15/large cheese
Wait time: 20-30 minutes

The best bang-for-buck pizza in Savannah.

What works: Generous toppings, good sauce-to-cheese ratio, and they don't skimp on portions. A large actually feeds 3-4 people here.

Specialty pick: The Mimi's Special ($19) with Italian sausage, peppers, and onions. Classic done right.

What sucks: The dining room looks like a 1990s rec room. But who cares? You're here for pizza, not Instagram shots.

Book a food tour if you want to hit multiple spots in one day, but honestly, Screamin' Mimi's alone is worth the trip.

4. Pizzeria Vittoria ★★★★

Location: 14 Whitaker St, Downtown
Price: $20/large cheese
Wait time: 15-20 minutes

Authentic Neapolitan-style pizza that doesn't feel pretentious.

What works: Imported San Marzano tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella option, proper 90-second cook time in a 900°F oven. The crust has those leopard spots and a soft, chewy texture.

Specialty pick: The Margherita DOC ($18) is textbook perfect. Simple ingredients, flawless execution.

What sucks: Small portions by American standards. One pie is barely enough for two hungry adults.

This is the spot for date night pizza, not post-bar carb loading.

💡 Pro tip: They serve wine. The house red for $7/glass pairs perfectly with their pies. Skip the overpriced beer.

5. Your Pie ★★★

Location: 22 E Broughton St, Broughton Shopping District
Price: $11/personal pizza
Wait time: 8-12 minutes

It's a chain, but it's the Chipotle of pizza—fast, customizable, consistent.

What works: Build-your-own model with unlimited toppings for one price. Brick oven, fast service, and you can watch them make it.

Specialty pick: Go custom. I did buffalo chicken, blue cheese, and banana peppers for $11. No upcharges.

What sucks: Personal pizzas only. No sharing option. If you're feeding a group, the math doesn't work.

This is laptop-friendly with decent WiFi. I worked here twice. Good for digital nomads between coworking sessions.

6. Rotelli Pizza & Pasta ★★★

Location: 225 E Bay St, River Street
Price: $19/large cheese
Wait time: 15-25 minutes

The only River Street pizza place worth mentioning.

What works: Thick-crust Sicilian-style option. Good for those who like doughy, filling pizza. They also do pasta if your group can't agree on pizza.

Specialty pick: The Sicilian Meat Lovers ($24) is a gut bomb in the best way.

What sucks: You're still paying the River Street tax. Same pizza would cost $15 elsewhere in Savannah.

Only go here if you're already on River Street and starving. Otherwise, walk 10 minutes to something better.

7. Mellow Mushroom ★★★

Location: 11 W Liberty St, Historic District
Price: $17/large cheese
Wait time: 20-30 minutes

Another chain, but they nail the hippie pizza aesthetic.

What works: Creative specialty pizzas, thick crust option, decent beer selection. The ingredients taste fresh, and they don't skimp on vegetables.

Specialty pick: The Holy Shiitake ($21) with mushrooms, caramelized onions, and mozzarella. Actually tasty for a veggie pizza.

What sucks: Inconsistent service. I've had great experiences and terrible ones here. Depends which staff is working.

Pizza Places In Savannah Ga is packed on weekends. Go weekday lunch if possible.

8. Little Italy Pizzeria ★★★

Location: 323 Eisenhower Dr, Southside
Price: $14/large cheese
Wait time: 10-15 minutes

Solid neighborhood spot. Nothing fancy, nothing terrible.

What works: Reliable, affordable, quick. The crust-to-topping ratio is balanced. They offer delivery, which most of these other spots don't.

Specialty pick: The Italian Sub Pizza ($18) tastes exactly like an Italian sub on pizza dough. If that sounds good to you, get it.

What sucks: Zero atmosphere. Strip mall location, fluorescent lighting. Pure takeout energy.

Order online, pick up, eat at your Airbnb. That's the move here.

💡 Pro tip: They run a Tuesday special—large one-topping for $9.99. I timed one of my visits for Tuesday. Worth it.

9. Emilio's Pizza ★★★

Location: 321 Fahm St, Landmark Historic District
Price: $16/large cheese
Wait time: 15-20 minutes

Old-school Italian joint run by an actual Italian family.

What works: Thin crust with a nice crisp, traditional red sauce, and they hand-toss the dough in front of you.

Specialty pick: The Emilio's Special ($20) with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and peppers. No surprises, just solid execution.

What sucks: Cash only. Yes, in 2026. There's an ATM inside, but it charges $3.50.

Come here if you want that authentic neighborhood pizzeria vibe without the tourist nonsense.

The 14 I'd Skip (And Why)

For pizza places in savannah ga, here's the brutal truth on the rest of the pizza places in Savannah GA:

I gave each of these spots a fair shot. They all disappointed in different ways, but the common thread? Tourist traps or poor quality control.

Price Comparison: What You're Actually Paying

For pizza places in savannah ga, here's the real cost breakdown per meal at the 9 winners:

Average pizza meal in Savannah: $10-13 per person at the good spots.

Compare that to Memphis soul food.

Worth it? Yeah. I'd eat this pizza tour again.